“When I was training for the Bar back in 1990, at one point I attended a voluntary course
of six evening classes at the Inns of Court School of Law which were devoted to body
language and non-verbal communication.
Given the sort of activities that I expected to undertake as a Barrister, it
seemed sensible to me to find out more about the current thinking when it came to
getting at the truth.
As a lawyer one is of course totally immersed in a world where “telling the truth, the
whole truth and nothing but the truth” is a fundamental element of the process – or put
another way, being able to see whether someone – a client, a witness (whether your
own or someone else’s) is telling lies.
My introduction to Dr Cliff Lansley was through exposure on TV in a real crime series on
the Warner Bros Discovery Channel – ‘Faking it – Tears of a Crime’. He was commenting
on a criminal case where he was able to demonstrate – using techniques and scientific
analysis which were quite new to me – that there was a very strong probability based on
evidence gleaned from the defendant himself (and only he) that the defendant was lying
through his teeth and explained how this can inform the investigative journey for more
efficient and effective closure of cases.
When I contacted Cliff to find out more about what I had seen on the TV, I found a
person who was totally committed to, and with great experience in, the analysis of non-
verbal communication in its broadest sense. He uses his company’s own SCAnS ® (Six
Channel Analysis System).
When I explained what it was that was at stake, it soon became apparent that (for him as
well as for me) we were in uncharted waters since far from my needing to demonstrate
that someone was guilty when they were arguing otherwise, my requirement was a need
for my client to be able to persuade others that he was innocent – or put another way,
that he was a reliable witness, and totally credible.
I very quickly learned in my early training that, broadly speaking, it did not matter to me
too much whether my client was telling the truth since my job was to present the case for
the client and leave it to others to decide where the truth lay. Of course, if it was clear
that what he said to me didn’t tally with other evidence that he had produced in support
of his case (whether civil or criminal) I would be obliged under the rule of my profession
to step down and suggest he found another Barrister, but the more I looked at the
subject of non-verbal communication, the more it seemed that its value is in establishing
the credibility with third parties (of a witness) and particularly so when it’s ‘one person’s
word against another’ – as happened to be the situation in the case I brought to Cliff’s
attention.
I became aware that Cliff has worked with a variety of different professionals, but he was
keen I think to explore how he can bring his methodology to the wider attention of the
legal profession to get SCAnS ® into the courtroom.
Clearly things have moved on since I studied the subject back in 1991 – and the
discovery that there is now a scientific method to help us make veracity judgments rather
than just one or two popular myths such as gaze aversion and rubbing one’s neck that
have no merit.
My client entered into the process in a very enthusiastic manner though – I have no
doubt – he was concerned about the prospect of being questioned by Cliff, one of the
conditions of his support. The operation involved analysis of various media recordings
and a 45-minute live interview by Cliff.
Having been informed at the outset that Cliff would know if he was not telling the truth –
which must have put him on his mettle – I do know that it has been of huge value to him
personally – for a number of reasons affecting his civil claim – but principally I think
because the whole process has given him the confidence which comes with knowing
that someone believes what you are telling them. I might add that I have never had any
doubt about the client’s honesty, and it has certainly been of value to me as his legal
representative to see my ‘gut feelings’ confirmed.
The process has involved a detailed analysis of video tapes of two types. Ot centred on
an Interview with Cliff, recorded in my clients home. In addition, I had also supplied Cliff
with CCTV footage of an incident which is at the centre of the claim. Also supplied was
video footage of the interview of my client under caution, conducted by a police officer.
You would need to obtain a copy of “Getting to the Truth” – Cliff’s book on the subject to
understand fully how the analysis of my clients behaviour was carried out. But reliable
conclusions can be obtained by the cross referencing of not just one or two
characteristics of the subjects behaviour and physiology but a triangulation of three
indicators across difference communication channels within seven seconds of a prompt,
from a staggering 27 research based cues – called ‘Points of Interest’.
I cannot possible here go into detail as to Cliff findings – but it was of particular interest
to learn that whilst his examination of my clients conduct under police interview
demonstrated that he (the client) was telling the truth to the police office – Cliff also
comments that it was his conclusion from behaviour that the policeman believed him –
which had a significance in the context of the case and the subsequent actions of the
police force involved.
Cliff’s forensic report was submitted into court as part of the claimant’s bundle at a
Judicial Review at a Substantive Hearing. The Judge highlighted the consistency
between the forensic report from Cliff and the belief from the interviewing officer that my
client was being truthful. Prior to this the position it was described as a finely balanced
case based on one person’s word against another.
I have learned much from my dealings with EmotionIntell (Emotional Intelligence
Academy), Cliff and their methodology. They have exceptional skills, and I would hope
that they will be able to bring the services that they can offer to a much wider audience
across the legal profession. I certainly would support any initiative which enabled them
to aid in the training of legal professionals such as Mediators and Solicitors as well as
Barristers. I have advanced the reasons why ‘Getting to the Truth’ is of particular interest
to me as a Barrister, but there are many others – and not least Judges – who would
benefit hugely from a better understanding of the value of what SCAnS ® , Cliff and his
team have to offer.
I commend EIA, Cliff, and the SCAnS ® methodology to anyone who just wants the truth.”
Mr Thomas Lamplugh Ballantine-Dykes
Barrister at Law
March 2026.